In this video, we walk through 5 ISC practice questions on the three parts of the NIST privacy framework. These questions are from ISC content area 2 on the AICPA CPA exam blueprints: Security, Confidentiality and Privacy.
The best way to use this video is to pause each time we get to a new question in the video, and then make your own attempt at the question before watching us go through it.
The Three Parts of the NIST Privacy Framework
The NIST Privacy Framework helps organizations manage privacy risk. Privacy risk is the chance that individuals will run into problems because of how an organization processes data about them. It’s related to cybersecurity risk but isn’t the same thing. A data breach is both a security problem and a privacy problem. Privacy problems can also come up when security is working perfectly, because the issue is what the organization itself chooses to do with the data.
Here’s an example. A fitness app company has never been breached, and its user data is encrypted and access-controlled. If the company starts combining users’ location history with their workout data and sharing the resulting profiles with advertisers, users face a privacy risk even though nothing has gone wrong with security. The Privacy Framework calls activities like this problematic data actions, and it’s designed to help organizations manage them.
Same Structure as the CSF
The Privacy Framework was built to match the structure of the NIST Cybersecurity Framework (CSF). It has three parts: the Framework Core, Framework Profiles, and Framework Implementation Tiers.
The Profiles and Tiers work the same way in both frameworks. A Current Profile describes the privacy outcomes the organization has achieved, a Target Profile describes the outcomes it wants to reach, and comparing the two shows the gaps. The Tiers use the same four levels as the CSF: Partial, Risk Informed, Repeatable, and Adaptive. These describe how formalized and consistent the organization’s privacy risk management is.
The Core
The Core is where the two frameworks differ. The Privacy Framework’s Core has five functions, in this order: Identify-P, Govern-P, Control-P, Communicate-P, and Protect-P.
Three of these share a name with a CSF function, though each focuses on privacy risk. Control-P and Communicate-P have no CSF equivalent. The CSF’s Detect, Respond, and Recover functions don’t appear in the Privacy Framework.
Identify-P and Govern-P
Identify-P is about understanding the privacy risks that come from the organization’s data processing. That means knowing what personal data the organization has, where it goes, which systems and outside vendors handle it, and how processing it could create problems for individuals. A health insurer cataloging the personal data it collects and mapping which vendors handle it is doing Identify-P work.
Govern-P sets up the organizational structure for managing privacy risk on an ongoing basis. It covers privacy policies, risk management strategy, staff training, and monitoring and reviewing the privacy program over time. In the Privacy Framework, Govern-P comes second, after Identify-P. The CSF lists Govern first.
Control-P and Communicate-P
Control-P is about managing how data is actually processed. It includes collecting only the data that’s needed, keeping data only as long as it serves a purpose, giving individuals a way to correct or delete their data, and using techniques like de-identification that make it harder to tell who the data is about. A ride-sharing app that collects only the data needed for rides, and deletes trip history once it’s no longer needed, is carrying out Control-P.
Communicate-P is about transparency. It covers how the organization tells individuals and other stakeholders about its data processing, such as privacy notices that explain what data is collected and why.
Protect-P and Data Breaches
Protect-P puts security safeguards around personal data, such as access controls, encryption, and maintaining the systems that store the data. This is where privacy and cybersecurity overlap.
Because the Privacy Framework has no Detect, Respond, or Recover functions, NIST intends the two frameworks to be used together. When personal data is breached, the organization relies on Protect-P to prevent the breach in the first place. It then uses the CSF’s Detect, Respond, and Recover functions to spot the breach, deal with it, and restore normal operations.










