TCP CPA Exam: Minimize Built-in Gains Tax for Asset Disposition

Minimize Built-in Gains Tax for Asset Disposition

Share This...

Introduction

Overview of Built-in Gains (BIG) Tax and Its Importance for Asset Disposition

In this article, we’ll cover minimize built-in gains tax for asset disposition. The built-in gains (BIG) tax is a specific tax imposed on S corporations that were previously C corporations and held appreciated assets at the time of conversion. This tax is designed to capture the tax on gains that were built into the assets during the C corporation years, but which are realized after the corporation has elected S status. In essence, the BIG tax prevents S corporations from avoiding tax on pre-existing gains by converting from C corporation status.

For corporations transitioning from C to S status, the BIG tax can significantly impact financial planning, especially when assets that appreciated under C corporation rules are sold or disposed of. Because the tax applies to the built-in gain realized upon the disposition of such assets, it is crucial for taxpayers and CPAs to plan strategically to minimize the overall tax burden during these transactions.

Context: Applicable to S Corporations Converting from C Corporations with Appreciated Assets

The BIG tax comes into play when a C corporation converts to an S corporation while holding appreciated assets. The appreciation in value that occurred while the entity was taxed as a C corporation is subject to BIG tax if the assets are disposed of during a specific period after the conversion, known as the recognition period (currently 5 years).

This is an important consideration for businesses with a history of holding valuable assets such as real estate, securities, or intellectual property. Disposing of these assets post-conversion, without proper planning, could lead to a significant tax liability. The BIG tax is calculated based on the fair market value of the assets at the time of the S corporation election, minus their tax basis.

Relevance to the TCP CPA Exam: Understanding Strategies for Minimizing BIG Tax During Asset Disposition

For those studying for the TCP CPA exam, it is essential to have a firm grasp on the rules surrounding built-in gains tax and the strategies to minimize or defer it. Understanding how and when the BIG tax is triggered is crucial for tax planning and advising clients on optimal asset disposition strategies within S corporations.

Exam candidates should be well-versed in the mechanics of the BIG tax, how to calculate it, and how to apply different strategies to mitigate the tax burden. These strategies include timing the sale of appreciated assets, utilizing installment sales, and offsetting gains with losses. Mastery of these techniques not only aids in exam preparation but also enhances practical skills needed for advising clients in real-world tax situations.

In the sections that follow, we will explore in detail the mechanics of the built-in gains tax, its calculation, and the most effective strategies for minimizing it during asset disposition.

Understanding Built-in Gains Tax

Definition of Built-in Gains (BIG) Tax

The built-in gains (BIG) tax is a federal tax imposed on S corporations that were formerly C corporations and had appreciated assets at the time of conversion. The tax is designed to prevent corporations from avoiding taxation on gains that accumulated during their time as a C corporation by converting to an S corporation. Essentially, the BIG tax applies to the unrealized appreciation (i.e., the built-in gain) of the corporation’s assets at the time of the transition from C to S status.

The BIG tax is only applicable if the appreciated assets are sold or disposed of within a specified period after the S corporation election. If the asset disposition happens outside of this window, the corporation may not be liable for the built-in gains tax, but within this period, the gain must be recognized and taxed accordingly.

Explanation of Circumstances That Trigger BIG Tax

The built-in gains tax is triggered in a specific set of circumstances, primarily when a C corporation converts to an S corporation and disposes of assets with built-in gains during the recognition period. Built-in gains refer to the amount by which the fair market value (FMV) of an asset exceeds its tax basis at the time of conversion.

For example, if a C corporation owns a piece of real estate that has appreciated in value from $500,000 to $800,000 at the time of conversion, the built-in gain of $300,000 would be subject to the BIG tax if the property is sold during the recognition period. The tax ensures that any appreciation that occurred while the company was a C corporation is subject to the appropriate taxation, even if the asset is sold after the conversion to an S corporation.

Triggering events for the BIG tax typically include:

  • Sale of appreciated assets that were held by the corporation during its time as a C corporation.
  • Distributions of such assets to shareholders.
  • Certain exchanges of assets, such as a taxable exchange.

Overview of the BIG Tax Rate and the Recognition Period

The recognition period is a critical concept in the built-in gains tax rules. It refers to the time frame during which an S corporation must recognize and pay tax on built-in gains if those assets are disposed of. Under current law, the recognition period is five years from the date of the S corporation election. If an appreciated asset is sold or otherwise disposed of within this five-year period, the built-in gains tax applies.

The BIG tax is generally imposed at the highest corporate tax rate in effect during the year of the asset’s disposition. Currently, this rate stands at 21% under federal law. This means that for every dollar of built-in gain recognized during the recognition period, the S corporation must pay a 21% tax.

It is important to note that the BIG tax applies to the built-in gain itself, and not to any gain that accrued after the conversion. Any appreciation that occurs after the S corporation election is subject to normal S corporation taxation, where gains are passed through to the shareholders and taxed at their individual tax rates.

By understanding the definition, triggers, tax rates, and the recognition period, businesses and CPAs can effectively navigate and plan for potential built-in gains tax liabilities, implementing strategies to minimize or defer this tax.

Asset Disposition in an S Corporation

Situations That Lead to Asset Disposition and the Potential for BIG Tax

In an S corporation, asset dispositions refer to the sale, exchange, or distribution of assets held by the corporation. When these assets were owned by the corporation at the time it was a C corporation and have appreciated in value, disposing of them can trigger the built-in gains (BIG) tax if the disposition occurs within the recognition period. Understanding the different scenarios that qualify as asset disposition is essential for anticipating when the BIG tax may apply.

Several key situations may lead to asset disposition and trigger the potential for BIG tax, including:

  • Sale of Appreciated Assets: One of the most common scenarios where BIG tax is triggered is the outright sale of assets. If the fair market value of an asset has increased since the corporation was a C corporation, selling that asset within the five-year recognition period will likely result in a built-in gains tax.
  • Exchange of Assets: Asset exchanges, such as a like-kind exchange under Section 1031 of the Internal Revenue Code, can also trigger BIG tax. In particular, if an asset with built-in gains is exchanged for another asset and the exchange is not tax-deferred, the built-in gains must be recognized, resulting in tax liability.
  • Distribution of Assets to Shareholders: When appreciated assets are distributed to shareholders, this is considered a taxable event that may trigger the recognition of built-in gains. The corporation will be required to calculate and pay the BIG tax on the difference between the fair market value of the asset and its tax basis.

In each of these situations, the potential for BIG tax arises because the corporation is effectively realizing the appreciation of the assets that occurred during its time as a C corporation.

Examples of Common Asset Dispositions That Trigger BIG Tax

There are several typical scenarios where asset disposition in an S corporation leads to the application of the built-in gains tax. These examples highlight how the tax rules work in practice:

  1. Sale of Real Estate Held by the Corporation
    • Scenario: A corporation owned a piece of real estate during its years as a C corporation, with a tax basis of $500,000. Upon converting to an S corporation, the fair market value of the property had risen to $800,000, creating a built-in gain of $300,000. If the S corporation sells the real estate for $850,000 within five years of the conversion, the built-in gain of $300,000 will be subject to the BIG tax.
    • Trigger: The disposition (sale) of appreciated property within the recognition period.
  2. Distribution of Appreciated Securities to Shareholders
    • Scenario: A former C corporation converted to an S corporation while holding a portfolio of securities. The securities had a fair market value of $1,000,000 and a tax basis of $700,000 at the time of conversion, resulting in a built-in gain of $300,000. Two years after the conversion, the corporation distributes the securities to its shareholders. The built-in gain of $300,000 will be recognized, and the corporation must pay BIG tax on the distribution.
    • Trigger: The distribution of appreciated assets to shareholders within the recognition period.
  3. Exchange of Machinery Under a Like-Kind Exchange
    • Scenario: A former C corporation converted to an S corporation while holding machinery with a tax basis of $100,000 and a fair market value of $200,000. Three years after the conversion, the corporation exchanges the machinery for new equipment under a transaction that does not qualify for tax deferral. The built-in gain of $100,000 must be recognized, and the corporation will pay BIG tax on the gain.
    • Trigger: The exchange of appreciated assets that do not qualify for tax deferral within the recognition period.

In all these examples, the built-in gains tax is triggered because the asset disposition occurs within the five-year recognition period, and the S corporation is effectively realizing the appreciation that occurred while it was taxed as a C corporation. Proper tax planning can help mitigate or defer these tax consequences, which we will explore in the subsequent sections.

Calculating Built-in Gains Tax

Steps to Calculate Built-in Gains Tax on Asset Disposition

Calculating built-in gains (BIG) tax on the disposition of appreciated assets held by an S corporation that was formerly a C corporation involves several key steps. The goal is to identify the portion of the asset’s value that is subject to the BIG tax, apply the appropriate tax rate, and determine the final tax liability. Here’s a step-by-step guide to calculating BIG tax:

1. Identify the Appreciation in Value of Assets Before S Corporation Conversion

The first step in calculating the built-in gains tax is to determine the appreciation in the value of the corporation’s assets at the time of conversion from a C corporation to an S corporation. This involves comparing the tax basis of each asset to its fair market value (FMV) as of the conversion date.

  • Tax Basis: The tax basis is the asset’s original cost or adjusted cost (after depreciation or improvements) for tax purposes.
  • Fair Market Value (FMV): The FMV is the price at which the asset could be sold in an open market as of the conversion date.

The difference between the FMV and the tax basis at the time of conversion is considered the built-in gain for that particular asset.

Example:

  • A piece of equipment owned by a C corporation has a tax basis of $100,000 but is worth $200,000 (FMV) at the time of conversion to an S corporation. The built-in gain is:
    Built-in Gain = FMV – Tax Basis = 200,000 – 100,000 = 100,000
    This $100,000 built-in gain is subject to the BIG tax if the equipment is sold or disposed of during the recognition period.

2. Determine the Built-in Gains Tax Rate

Once the built-in gain is identified, the next step is to apply the built-in gains tax rate. The BIG tax is calculated at the highest federal corporate tax rate in effect for the year in which the asset is disposed of. As of the current tax law, the rate is 21%.

This means that any built-in gain recognized during the recognition period will be taxed at 21%, which is the same rate applied to regular corporate taxable income.

3. Calculate the Amount of Built-in Gains Tax Owed Upon Disposition

The final step is to calculate the actual tax liability by applying the built-in gains tax rate to the built-in gain. This gives you the amount of tax owed on the disposition of the asset.

Example:

  • Continuing from the previous example, let’s assume the equipment with a built-in gain of $100,000 is sold within the recognition period. The built-in gains tax would be calculated as follows:
    BIG Tax = Built-in Gain x BIG Tax Rate = 100,000 x 21% = 21,000
    Therefore, the S corporation must pay $21,000 in built-in gains tax upon the sale of the equipment.

Summary of Steps

  1. Identify the Built-in Gain: Subtract the tax basis from the fair market value at the time of conversion to determine the built-in gain for the asset.
  2. Apply the BIG Tax Rate: Use the current federal corporate tax rate (21%) to calculate the tax owed on the built-in gain.
  3. Calculate the BIG Tax Liability: Multiply the built-in gain by the BIG tax rate to determine the amount of tax owed.

By following these steps, S corporations and their CPAs can accurately calculate the built-in gains tax on asset dispositions and plan for tax liabilities accordingly.

Minimizing Built-in Gains Tax

Timing the Disposition

One of the most effective strategies for minimizing the built-in gains (BIG) tax is to carefully time the disposition of appreciated assets. Specifically, waiting until the recognition period expires can entirely eliminate the BIG tax liability, making this a powerful tax planning tool.

Strategy: Wait Out the Recognition Period (Currently 5 Years)

The recognition period is the time frame during which an S corporation must recognize and pay built-in gains tax on the appreciation of assets held at the time of its conversion from a C corporation. Currently, this period is five years. If an appreciated asset is sold or otherwise disposed of within this five-year window, the built-in gains tax applies. However, once the recognition period ends, the S corporation is no longer liable for the BIG tax on the appreciation that occurred during its time as a C corporation.

The strategy here is simple but impactful: wait out the recognition period before disposing of assets with significant built-in gains. By holding onto the assets until the five-year window has passed, the S corporation can avoid the built-in gains tax altogether, and any appreciation will only be subject to the standard S corporation pass-through tax rules.

Impact of Holding Assets Until the Recognition Period Expires

The decision to hold assets until the recognition period expires can have substantial tax benefits, as it allows the S corporation to avoid paying the 21% federal corporate tax rate on the built-in gain. This could lead to significant tax savings, especially for highly appreciated assets such as real estate, securities, or intellectual property.

Example:

  • Suppose an S corporation holds a piece of real estate with a built-in gain of $500,000 at the time of its conversion from a C corporation. If the real estate is sold within the five-year recognition period, the corporation would be subject to a built-in gains tax of 21%, amounting to $105,000 in tax liability.
    BIG Tax = 500,000 x 21% = 105,000
  • However, if the corporation waits until the recognition period has passed before selling the property, the built-in gains tax will no longer apply, and the $105,000 tax liability can be avoided entirely.

The key impact of this strategy is that by holding onto the asset for at least five years post-conversion, the corporation can sell it without the burden of BIG tax, significantly reducing the overall tax liability. This approach allows S corporations to optimize their financial outcomes by deferring the sale of appreciated assets until the recognition period expires.

Considerations for Using the Strategy:

  • Cash Flow Needs: While holding an asset to avoid the BIG tax can lead to substantial tax savings, the corporation must also consider its cash flow needs. Delaying the sale of an asset to wait out the recognition period may not be feasible if the corporation requires liquidity.
  • Market Conditions: In addition to the recognition period, market conditions should be considered. If the asset’s value is expected to decline, it may not make financial sense to hold it just to avoid the BIG tax.
  • Other Tax Planning Strategies: This strategy can be combined with others, such as installment sales or offsetting gains with losses, to further minimize tax liabilities.

By strategically timing asset dispositions and waiting out the recognition period, S corporations can effectively minimize or even eliminate the built-in gains tax, leading to more favorable financial outcomes.

Offset Gains with Built-in Losses

Another effective strategy to minimize the built-in gains (BIG) tax is to offset built-in gains with built-in losses from assets that have declined in value. By strategically disposing of assets that have decreased in value, S corporations can reduce or eliminate their taxable built-in gains, lowering the overall tax liability.

Strategy: Offset BIG Gains with Built-in Losses from Assets That Have Declined in Value

S corporations that have converted from C corporation status may have a mix of appreciated and depreciated assets at the time of conversion. While built-in gains are subject to the BIG tax when the appreciated assets are disposed of during the recognition period, assets that have declined in value—known as built-in losses—can be used to offset these gains.

The strategy involves selling or disposing of both appreciated and depreciated assets within the same tax year. By doing so, the built-in losses can be applied against the built-in gains, reducing the overall amount of taxable gains subject to the BIG tax. This approach helps mitigate the tax burden by leveraging losses to counterbalance gains, effectively reducing the corporation’s BIG tax liability.

Explanation of How This Reduces the Overall Tax Liability

When an S corporation sells an asset with a built-in loss, that loss is deducted from the built-in gains, reducing the net gain subject to the BIG tax. This strategy works similarly to the general tax principle of offsetting capital gains with capital losses, but specifically applies to built-in gains and losses recognized during the BIG tax recognition period.

Example:

  • Suppose an S corporation holds two assets at the time of conversion from a C corporation:
    • Asset 1: Appreciated real estate with a built-in gain of $300,000.
    • Asset 2: Machinery with a built-in loss of $100,000.
  • If the corporation sells both assets within the five-year recognition period, it can use the $100,000 built-in loss from the machinery to offset the $300,000 built-in gain from the real estate. The net built-in gain subject to the BIG tax would be reduced to $200,000:
    Net Built-in Gain = 300,000 – 100,000 = 200,000
  • Without this offset, the corporation would have paid the 21% BIG tax on the full $300,000 built-in gain, resulting in a tax liability of $63,000:
    300,000 x 21% = 63,000
  • By offsetting the built-in gain with the built-in loss, the corporation reduces its taxable gain to $200,000, lowering its tax liability to $42,000:
    200,000 x 21% = 42,000

This results in a tax savings of $21,000, illustrating how offsetting built-in gains with built-in losses can significantly reduce the overall tax burden.

Additional Considerations:

  • Asset Management: The corporation needs to carefully identify and manage its assets to take advantage of this strategy, ensuring that built-in losses are recognized in the same tax year as built-in gains.
  • Timing of Dispositions: Timing is crucial, as the corporation must dispose of both appreciated and depreciated assets within the recognition period to fully leverage this offset strategy.
  • Maximizing Losses: In some cases, it may be beneficial to recognize built-in losses earlier in the recognition period to offset anticipated gains from future asset sales.

By utilizing this strategy, S corporations can effectively reduce the impact of the built-in gains tax and optimize their overall tax position during the recognition period.

Installment Sales Strategy

Another effective approach to minimize the built-in gains (BIG) tax is the use of installment sales. This strategy allows S corporations to spread the recognition of gains over multiple years, which can help reduce the immediate tax burden and provide flexibility in tax planning.

Using Installment Sales to Spread Out the Gains Over Multiple Years

An installment sale occurs when the seller receives at least one payment after the tax year in which the sale occurs. Rather than recognizing the entire built-in gain in the year of the asset’s sale, the S corporation can defer part of the gain by receiving payments over several years. Each payment received is treated as a combination of a return of capital, gain, and interest, with the gain portion subject to taxation.

For S corporations with built-in gains, this strategy is particularly beneficial because it allows the corporation to spread the recognition of those gains over time, potentially reducing the total built-in gains tax owed during the recognition period.

How It Works:

  • When an S corporation sells an asset using an installment sale, the gain recognized each year is based on the payments received during that year.
  • The corporation only pays BIG tax on the portion of the built-in gain that corresponds to the payments received within the recognition period.

Example:

  • Assume an S corporation sells a piece of real estate with a built-in gain of $500,000 and decides to structure the sale as an installment sale, receiving $100,000 per year over five years.
  • The built-in gains tax is applied only to the portion of the gain recognized in each year’s installment payment. If the recognition period extends for three more years, the corporation will pay BIG tax on the built-in gains from the payments received in those three years. The gains from the payments received after the recognition period ends will not be subject to BIG tax, as the five-year window will have closed.

Benefits of Deferring the Recognition of Built-in Gains

There are several advantages to using an installment sales strategy to defer the recognition of built-in gains:

  1. Spread Out the Tax Liability:
    • By recognizing the gain over several years, the S corporation can avoid paying the full built-in gains tax in a single year. This reduces the immediate tax burden and allows the corporation to manage cash flow more effectively.
  2. Potential Reduction in Overall BIG Tax:
    • If the installment payments extend beyond the five-year recognition period, the S corporation will only be liable for the BIG tax on the payments received within that period. Once the recognition period expires, no further built-in gains tax is due on payments made afterward, even though the asset sale is still generating revenue.
  3. Flexibility in Tax Planning:
    • Installment sales provide greater flexibility in managing taxable income and gains. The corporation can plan for payments in years where other deductions or losses may offset the gain, further minimizing the tax impact.

Example of Installment Sales Savings:

  • Suppose an S corporation sells an asset for $600,000, with a built-in gain of $300,000. The sale is structured as an installment sale, where the buyer makes five equal annual payments of $120,000. The built-in gain component of each payment would be $60,000 ($300,000 ÷ 5).
  • If the S corporation’s recognition period ends after year three, the corporation would only pay BIG tax on the built-in gains portion of the payments received in the first three years, which amounts to $180,000 ($60,000 × 3). The remaining $120,000 of built-in gain recognized in years four and five would not be subject to the BIG tax.

By deferring recognition of gains through an installment sale, the S corporation reduces its immediate tax liability and may even eliminate a portion of its BIG tax obligation if payments extend beyond the recognition period.

The installment sales strategy offers S corporations a way to minimize their built-in gains tax by spreading out taxable gains and taking advantage of the expiration of the recognition period. It provides flexibility and control over the timing of tax payments, making it a valuable tool in tax planning.

Cost Segregation and Depreciation

Cost segregation and accelerated depreciation methods can be powerful tools for minimizing built-in gains (BIG) tax by reducing the taxable gains associated with depreciable property. By identifying and accelerating the depreciation of specific components of an asset, S corporations can effectively reduce the overall tax burden when disposing of these assets during the recognition period.

Accelerated Depreciation Methods as a Means of Reducing Taxable Gains

Accelerated depreciation allows S corporations to recover the costs of assets more quickly by increasing depreciation deductions in the early years of an asset’s useful life. This results in a lower tax basis for the asset at the time of disposition, but it also means that more of the asset’s value has already been deducted over time, thus reducing the built-in gains subject to the BIG tax.

Cost segregation is a tax strategy that involves breaking down assets, particularly real estate, into different components that can be depreciated over shorter timeframes using accelerated depreciation methods. For example, instead of depreciating an entire building over 39 years, components such as plumbing, electrical systems, and flooring can be depreciated over much shorter periods (e.g., 5, 7, or 15 years). This front-loading of depreciation can significantly reduce taxable gains upon asset disposition, particularly within the recognition period.

By utilizing accelerated depreciation methods, S corporations can reduce the amount of built-in gain on depreciable property, which lowers the BIG tax liability when the asset is sold or disposed of.

Example of How Cost Segregation Can Minimize BIG Tax

Scenario:

  • An S corporation that was previously a C corporation owns a commercial building. The building’s total cost basis is $1,000,000, and at the time of conversion to an S corporation, its fair market value is $1,500,000, resulting in a built-in gain of $500,000.
  • Without cost segregation, the building would be depreciated over 39 years under standard tax rules. After five years, the accumulated depreciation might only reduce the tax basis by a small amount, leaving a large built-in gain when the asset is sold during the recognition period.

Cost Segregation in Action:

  • The corporation conducts a cost segregation study and identifies $400,000 of the building’s components (e.g., electrical, HVAC, fixtures) that can be depreciated over a shorter period—15 years or less—using accelerated depreciation.
  • By accelerating depreciation on these components, the corporation can claim larger depreciation deductions in the early years, thereby significantly reducing the building’s remaining tax basis. Over five years, the corporation may have depreciated an additional $200,000 compared to straight-line depreciation for the entire building.

Result:

  • When the building is sold within the recognition period, the adjusted tax basis will be lower due to the additional depreciation deductions, reducing the amount of built-in gain.
  • Suppose the accelerated depreciation reduces the tax basis of the building to $700,000 instead of $800,000. The built-in gain subject to the BIG tax is now reduced to $400,000 instead of $500,000.

BIG Tax Calculation Without Cost Segregation:

  • Built-in gain: $500,000
  • BIG tax: $500,000 × 21% = $105,000

BIG Tax Calculation With Cost Segregation:

  • Built-in gain: $400,000
  • BIG tax: $400,000 × 21% = $84,000

By using cost segregation and accelerated depreciation methods, the S corporation reduces its BIG tax liability by $21,000 in this example.

Benefits of This Strategy:

  • Increased Cash Flow: By front-loading depreciation, the S corporation can reduce its taxable income in the early years, resulting in immediate tax savings and improved cash flow.
  • Lower Built-in Gain: Accelerating depreciation reduces the tax basis of the property more quickly, which in turn reduces the amount of built-in gain subject to BIG tax at the time of asset disposition.
  • Strategic Planning: Cost segregation allows for detailed asset management, enabling the corporation to plan for asset dispositions in a tax-efficient manner.

Cost segregation and accelerated depreciation methods offer an effective way to minimize built-in gains tax by reducing the taxable gains associated with depreciable assets. Through careful planning, S corporations can optimize their tax position and potentially save significant amounts in built-in gains tax.

Charitable Contributions of Appreciated Property

A unique strategy for minimizing built-in gains (BIG) tax is to contribute appreciated property to a qualified charity. This approach can help S corporations avoid recognizing built-in gains on the appreciation of assets while also receiving a charitable deduction, leading to both tax savings and philanthropic benefits.

Contributing Appreciated Assets to a Charity to Avoid Recognizing the Built-in Gains

When an S corporation contributes appreciated property to a qualified charitable organization, the corporation does not need to recognize the built-in gains associated with the donated asset. This is because, under the Internal Revenue Code, gifts to charities are generally exempt from capital gains tax, and the built-in gain does not need to be reported.

By transferring ownership of an appreciated asset to a charity instead of selling it, the corporation avoids the BIG tax that would otherwise be triggered if the asset were sold during the recognition period. The fair market value of the property at the time of the donation is eligible for a charitable contribution deduction, subject to certain limitations.

This strategy is particularly useful for highly appreciated assets that would otherwise result in a large built-in gain if sold. It allows the corporation to benefit from the asset’s value without having to pay tax on the built-in gain.

Tax Benefits and Limitations of This Strategy

Tax Benefits:

  1. Avoidance of Built-in Gains Tax: By donating the asset rather than selling it, the corporation avoids the 21% built-in gains tax on the appreciation that occurred while the corporation was still a C corporation.
    Example:
    • Assume an S corporation holds stock with a built-in gain of $100,000. If the corporation sells the stock, it would incur a BIG tax liability of $21,000 (21% of $100,000). However, if the corporation donates the stock to a qualified charity, it avoids the BIG tax entirely.
  2. Charitable Deduction: The corporation can deduct the fair market value of the donated asset as a charitable contribution, reducing its taxable income. The deduction is generally limited to a certain percentage of the corporation’s taxable income, typically 10% for corporations, with the excess carried forward to future tax years.
    Example:
    • If the fair market value of the donated stock is $150,000, the S corporation can deduct this amount from its taxable income (subject to limitations), reducing its overall tax liability.
  3. Philanthropic Impact: Beyond the tax benefits, contributing appreciated assets allows corporations to support charitable causes, aligning with corporate social responsibility goals and potentially improving public perception.

Limitations:

  1. Charitable Deduction Limits: The deduction for charitable contributions is subject to specific limits based on the corporation’s taxable income. For most corporations, the deduction is limited to 10% of taxable income, though any excess amount can be carried forward for up to five years. If the corporation’s taxable income is low in the year of donation, it may not be able to use the full deduction immediately.
  2. Fair Market Value Limitation for Certain Property: The deduction for certain types of appreciated property, such as inventory or short-term capital gain property, is limited to the corporation’s cost basis rather than the fair market value. This reduces the benefit of the donation in cases where the property has not been held for long-term appreciation.
  3. Loss of Potential Cash from Sale: While donating appreciated property avoids built-in gains tax, it also means the corporation does not receive cash from the sale of the asset. The decision to donate should therefore be weighed against the potential need for liquidity.

Example of Benefits and Limitations:

  • Suppose an S corporation owns appreciated real estate with a fair market value of $1,000,000 and a tax basis of $500,000, creating a built-in gain of $500,000. If the corporation sells the property, it would incur a built-in gains tax of $105,000 (21% of $500,000).
  • Alternatively, the corporation could donate the property to a qualified charity. By doing so, it avoids the $105,000 BIG tax and is eligible for a charitable contribution deduction of $1,000,000 (the fair market value). However, this deduction would be limited to 10% of the corporation’s taxable income, with the remainder carried forward to future tax years.
  • If the corporation needs liquidity from the property, the donation might not be the best strategy. On the other hand, if the corporation is looking for a tax-efficient way to support a charitable cause, this strategy provides both a philanthropic benefit and significant tax savings.

Contributing appreciated property to a charity is a tax-efficient way for S corporations to avoid built-in gains tax while supporting charitable endeavors. However, this strategy requires careful consideration of the corporation’s overall tax situation, liquidity needs, and the specific limitations on charitable deductions.

Like-Kind Exchanges (Section 1031)

One of the most effective strategies for deferring the recognition of built-in gains (BIG) on the disposition of real property is through a like-kind exchange under Section 1031 of the Internal Revenue Code. This provision allows S corporations to defer capital gains, including built-in gains, when they exchange qualifying real property for other real property of a like-kind. This strategy enables the deferral of BIG tax until the newly acquired property is sold or disposed of in a taxable transaction.

Using Section 1031 Exchanges to Defer Recognition of Gains When Disposing of Real Property

A Section 1031 like-kind exchange allows S corporations to exchange real property used for business or held for investment without immediately recognizing capital gains, including built-in gains. Instead of triggering the BIG tax by selling appreciated real property, the corporation can defer the gain by acquiring similar property in exchange.

The tax deferral applies to the built-in gain on the original property, meaning the corporation does not have to pay the BIG tax at the time of the exchange. The gain is carried forward to the new property, which inherits the tax basis of the old property, deferring the tax liability until the new property is eventually sold or disposed of in a taxable transaction.

This deferral can be particularly useful for real estate investments, where property values often appreciate over time, leading to significant built-in gains. By exchanging appreciated property for like-kind property, S corporations can avoid immediate taxation and continue to invest in real estate without incurring BIG tax during the recognition period.

Criteria for Eligibility and Benefits of Like-Kind Exchanges

To qualify for the deferral of built-in gains tax under a Section 1031 exchange, certain criteria must be met:

  1. Real Property Requirement:
    • As of the changes in the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017, Section 1031 exchanges are limited to real property. Personal property no longer qualifies for like-kind exchanges. Therefore, only real estate held for investment or business purposes can be exchanged under Section 1031.
  2. Like-Kind Property:
    • The properties involved in the exchange must be of “like-kind.” For real estate, this term is broadly interpreted, meaning that most types of real estate—such as commercial properties, rental properties, or undeveloped land—can be exchanged for one another. The properties do not have to be identical, but they must both be used for business or investment purposes. Example:
    • An S corporation that owns an office building could exchange it for a rental apartment complex or a parcel of undeveloped land, provided both are used for business or investment purposes.
  3. Proper Exchange Structure:
    • The exchange must be structured properly to qualify for tax deferral. A common method is a deferred exchange, where the corporation sells its property and uses the proceeds to purchase like-kind property within a specified timeframe.
    • There are specific time limits to adhere to:
      • 45-day identification period: The corporation must identify potential replacement properties within 45 days of selling the original property.
      • 180-day exchange period: The corporation must complete the acquisition of the replacement property within 180 days of the sale of the original property.
  4. Use of Qualified Intermediary:
    • A qualified intermediary (QI) is typically required to facilitate the exchange, holding the proceeds from the sale of the original property and applying them toward the purchase of the replacement property. The corporation cannot directly receive the proceeds, or the transaction will not qualify for Section 1031 treatment.

Benefits of Like-Kind Exchanges

The primary benefit of a like-kind exchange is the deferral of built-in gains tax, allowing S corporations to avoid triggering a taxable event at the time of the property disposition. This deferral offers several significant advantages:

  1. BIG Tax Deferral:
    • If the S corporation holds real estate with a substantial built-in gain, a like-kind exchange allows the corporation to defer the BIG tax liability, potentially beyond the recognition period. The tax is not eliminated, but rather deferred until the eventual sale of the replacement property.
    • For example, if a property has a built-in gain of $500,000, a Section 1031 exchange defers the 21% BIG tax on this gain, allowing the corporation to reinvest the proceeds into another property without incurring immediate tax liability.
  2. Continued Investment in Real Property:
    • The corporation can exchange one appreciated property for another, continuing to invest in real estate while preserving cash flow that would otherwise be used to pay taxes. This allows the corporation to expand or improve its real estate portfolio without incurring a current tax liability.
  3. Potential for Permanent Tax Deferral:
    • In some cases, the built-in gain can be deferred indefinitely if the replacement property is never sold. For example, the gain can be passed on to heirs through an estate, where the tax basis is stepped up to the property’s fair market value at the time of death, effectively eliminating the deferred tax.
  4. Tax Deferral Beyond Recognition Period:
    • If the replacement property is held beyond the recognition period, the built-in gains tax may be permanently deferred since the gains are only recognized upon a taxable event, such as the sale of the property. Once the recognition period has passed, there is no BIG tax on the eventual sale of the replacement property.

Example:

  • An S corporation owns a commercial building with a built-in gain of $400,000. Rather than selling the building and paying $84,000 in built-in gains tax (21% of $400,000), the corporation engages in a Section 1031 exchange, trading the building for a new office property. The gain of $400,000 is deferred, and the new property inherits the original building’s tax basis. The corporation continues to own and use the new property without paying the BIG tax at the time of the exchange.

Section 1031 like-kind exchanges offer S corporations a valuable strategy for deferring built-in gains tax on real property. By carefully structuring the exchange and ensuring compliance with eligibility requirements, corporations can reinvest in new real estate while deferring taxes, improving both cash flow and investment potential.

Exceptions and Exemptions to Built-in Gains Tax

While the built-in gains (BIG) tax is designed to capture gains on appreciated assets when a C corporation converts to an S corporation, there are certain exceptions and exemptions that can prevent or reduce the application of this tax. Understanding these exceptions can help S corporations minimize or eliminate their BIG tax liability in certain scenarios.

Identifying Potential Exceptions to BIG Tax

One key exception to the built-in gains tax occurs when assets held by the corporation did not appreciate during the time the entity was taxed as a C corporation. The BIG tax applies only to the portion of an asset’s appreciation that occurred before the S corporation election. If certain assets did not increase in value during the C corporation years, any gains recognized from the sale of those assets after the conversion may not be subject to the BIG tax.

Criteria for Exception:

  • No Appreciation During C Corporation Years: If the fair market value (FMV) of the asset at the time of the S corporation conversion is equal to or less than the asset’s tax basis, there is no built-in gain to tax. Any future appreciation occurring after the S corporation election is not subject to BIG tax and is instead taxed under the normal pass-through rules for S corporations. Example:
  • A C corporation owns a piece of equipment with a tax basis of $100,000 and an FMV of $95,000 at the time of its conversion to an S corporation. Since the equipment’s FMV is lower than its tax basis, there is no built-in gain. If the equipment is later sold at a gain, that gain is not subject to the BIG tax because no appreciation occurred during the C corporation years.
  • Assets Acquired After the S Corporation Conversion: Assets purchased or acquired after the corporation has elected S status are not subject to the BIG tax because they have no built-in gain from the C corporation period. Gains from the sale of these assets will be taxed under S corporation rules, passing through to shareholders without the application of BIG tax.

Application of Tax-Free Reorganizations or Liquidations Under Certain Conditions

Another way to avoid or mitigate built-in gains tax is through specific tax-free reorganizations or liquidations. Under certain conditions, reorganizations or liquidations may not trigger the BIG tax, allowing for the transfer or disposition of assets without the immediate recognition of built-in gains.

1. Tax-Free Reorganizations (Section 368):

  • Certain corporate reorganizations can qualify for tax-deferred treatment under Section 368 of the Internal Revenue Code. These reorganizations, often referred to as “tax-free reorganizations,” allow the S corporation to restructure or merge with another entity without recognizing built-in gains.
  • Types of Qualifying Reorganizations:
    • Mergers and Consolidations: If the S corporation merges with or consolidates into another corporation in a transaction qualifying under Section 368(a), built-in gains may not be immediately recognized, allowing for a deferral of the BIG tax.
    • Recapitalizations: If the S corporation engages in a recapitalization that meets the requirements of a tax-free reorganization, the built-in gains may be deferred, as no immediate taxable event occurs.
    • Stock-for-Stock or Stock-for-Assets Exchanges: When the S corporation exchanges its stock or assets with another corporation in a qualifying reorganization, the transaction may be structured to avoid triggering built-in gains.
    Example:
  • An S corporation with appreciated assets engages in a qualifying merger under Section 368(a) with another S corporation. Because the reorganization qualifies as tax-free, the built-in gains are not recognized at the time of the merger, allowing the corporation to defer the BIG tax.

2. Tax-Free Liquidations (Section 332):

  • In some cases, an S corporation can undergo a tax-free liquidation under Section 332 of the Internal Revenue Code, which allows for the distribution of the corporation’s assets to a parent corporation without recognizing built-in gains. This provision typically applies in situations where a parent corporation owns at least 80% of the subsidiary S corporation’s stock.
  • Under Section 332, the subsidiary’s liquidation into the parent corporation can occur without triggering immediate recognition of gains or losses, including built-in gains, as long as certain conditions are met. This can result in the deferral or elimination of the BIG tax. Example:
  • A C corporation that converted to an S corporation is owned 100% by a parent corporation. The S corporation undergoes a tax-free liquidation under Section 332, distributing its appreciated assets to the parent corporation without triggering the built-in gains tax.

3. Other Exemptions:

  • Certain assets may be subject to other exemptions that allow for tax-deferred treatment. For instance, assets transferred in connection with a tax-free spinoff under Section 355 may also avoid the immediate recognition of built-in gains.

Key Considerations:

  • Proper Planning is Essential: To qualify for these exceptions and exemptions, the transactions must meet specific IRS requirements. Improper structuring of reorganizations or liquidations could result in the recognition of built-in gains, negating the potential tax benefits.
  • Timing of Transactions: The timing of these transactions can also be crucial. For example, some reorganizations and liquidations may need to occur within the recognition period to take advantage of the BIG tax deferral provisions.

While built-in gains tax is designed to capture gains on appreciated assets, certain exceptions and exemptions allow S corporations to avoid or defer this tax. By identifying assets that did not appreciate during the C corporation years and carefully structuring tax-free reorganizations or liquidations, S corporations can mitigate their BIG tax liability and achieve more favorable tax outcomes.

Case Studies/Examples

Example 1: Sale of Appreciated Real Estate Held by an S Corporation After Conversion from a C Corporation

Scenario:
A C corporation owns a commercial building with a tax basis of $600,000. At the time of the corporation’s conversion to an S corporation, the fair market value (FMV) of the building is $1,000,000, resulting in a built-in gain of $400,000. Three years after the conversion, the S corporation sells the building for $1,200,000.

Analysis:

  • The built-in gain at the time of conversion was $400,000 (FMV of $1,000,000 minus the tax basis of $600,000).
  • Upon selling the property for $1,200,000, the corporation realizes a total gain of $600,000.
  • $400,000 of this gain is subject to the built-in gains tax because it represents appreciation that occurred during the C corporation years.
  • The remaining $200,000 of the gain is not subject to the BIG tax, as it reflects appreciation that occurred after the S corporation election.

BIG Tax Calculation:

  • The built-in gain of $400,000 is subject to the current 21% BIG tax rate:
    BIG Tax = 400,000 x 21% = 84,000
  • The S corporation will owe $84,000 in built-in gains tax.

By selling the property within the recognition period, the S corporation triggers the BIG tax on the pre-conversion appreciation. Proper planning could have included exploring options like deferring the sale until after the recognition period or engaging in a Section 1031 like-kind exchange to avoid or defer the BIG tax.

Example 2: Using an Installment Sale to Defer the Recognition of Built-in Gains

Scenario:
An S corporation, previously a C corporation, owns a piece of land with a built-in gain of $300,000 at the time of conversion (FMV of $500,000, tax basis of $200,000). The corporation sells the land for $600,000, using an installment sale where the buyer makes payments of $120,000 annually for five years.

Analysis:

  • Under the installment sale method, the S corporation only recognizes a portion of the built-in gain each year, as payments are received.
  • Each payment consists of a mix of return of capital and gain. Since the total gain is $400,000 ($600,000 – $200,000), the portion of each $120,000 payment that is treated as a gain is $80,000 ($400,000 ÷ 5 years).

BIG Tax Calculation:

  • The built-in gain of $300,000 must be proportionally applied across the five installment payments:
    \(\text{BIG Gain Per Payment} = \left(\frac{300,000}{400,000}\right) \times 120,000 = 90,000 \)
  • The S corporation recognizes $90,000 in built-in gains each year. During the first three years, when payments are received within the recognition period, the corporation is liable for BIG tax:
    BIG Tax Each Year = 90,000 x 21% = 18,900
    Total BIG tax over three years: $18,900 × 3 = $56,700.
  • Payments received in years four and five (after the recognition period) are not subject to the built-in gains tax.

By using an installment sale, the S corporation defers a significant portion of the built-in gains tax, reducing its immediate tax liability and spreading the tax impact over several years. Additionally, payments received after the recognition period escape the BIG tax entirely.

Example 3: Offsetting BIG Gains with Built-in Losses from Underperforming Assets

Scenario:
An S corporation holds two assets at the time of its conversion from a C corporation:

  • Asset 1: Appreciated stock with a built-in gain of $250,000.
  • Asset 2: Machinery with a built-in loss of $100,000.

The S corporation plans to sell both assets within the recognition period.

Analysis:

  • Without any offset, the $250,000 built-in gain from Asset 1 would be subject to the BIG tax. However, the corporation can reduce its taxable built-in gains by using the $100,000 built-in loss from Asset 2 to offset part of the gain.

BIG Tax Calculation:

  • Net built-in gain:
    Net Built-in Gain = 250,000 – 100,000 = 150,000
  • The corporation is only liable for the BIG tax on the remaining $150,000 of built-in gain:
    BIG Tax = 150,000 x 21% = 31,500

By offsetting the gains from the sale of appreciated stock with the losses from the machinery, the corporation reduces its taxable built-in gains, saving $21,000 in BIG tax that it would have otherwise owed.

These case studies illustrate how various strategies—timing asset dispositions, structuring installment sales, and offsetting gains with losses—can significantly reduce or defer built-in gains tax, helping S corporations manage their tax liabilities more efficiently.

Tax Planning Considerations for CPAs

Effective tax planning is critical for CPAs to help S corporations minimize their built-in gains (BIG) tax liabilities. Careful consideration of the timing, structure, and strategy behind asset dispositions can result in significant tax savings. Below are key tax planning considerations CPAs should keep in mind when advising clients on the BIG tax.

Role of Tax Planning in Minimizing BIG Tax

Tax planning plays a pivotal role in minimizing the impact of the built-in gains tax. CPAs must carefully assess a corporation’s asset portfolio, especially after a C corporation converts to an S corporation, to determine which assets are subject to the BIG tax and how to strategically manage their disposition.

The following are key roles tax planning plays in minimizing BIG tax:

  • Timing Asset Dispositions: One of the most straightforward strategies is delaying asset sales until after the recognition period (currently five years). CPAs must advise clients on how to strategically time the sale of appreciated assets to avoid triggering BIG tax during the recognition period.
  • Deferring Gains with Installment Sales or Like-Kind Exchanges: CPAs can recommend using installment sales to spread out gains over multiple years or employing Section 1031 like-kind exchanges to defer gains altogether. Both strategies allow the corporation to defer or reduce the immediate recognition of built-in gains.
  • Offsetting Gains with Losses: For clients holding both appreciated and depreciated assets, CPAs should consider planning sales that offset built-in gains with built-in losses to minimize the overall tax liability.

Proactive tax planning ensures that the corporation’s financial and tax goals are aligned, allowing for tax-efficient decision-making regarding asset dispositions.

Importance of Thorough Documentation and Calculations

Thorough documentation and accurate calculations are essential when planning for and reporting built-in gains tax. Inadequate documentation or incorrect calculations can result in missed opportunities for tax savings or noncompliance with tax regulations, leading to penalties and interest. CPAs must ensure:

  • Accurate Valuation of Assets at Conversion: It’s critical to document the fair market value of all assets at the time of conversion from C corporation to S corporation. This value is essential for calculating built-in gains and losses, and the documentation should be comprehensive and verifiable.
  • Tracking of Depreciation and Adjustments: CPAs must maintain accurate records of any depreciation, improvements, or other tax adjustments made to the corporation’s assets post-conversion, as these can impact the calculation of built-in gains or losses.
  • Detailed Tax Calculations: Calculating BIG tax requires precision, particularly when applying strategies like installment sales, cost segregation, or offsetting gains with losses. CPAs should ensure that all calculations related to built-in gains tax liabilities are properly documented and verifiable.

Detailed documentation also serves as a safeguard in the event of an IRS audit, providing clear evidence of how tax liabilities were calculated and how the corporation managed its asset dispositions.

Key Considerations for CPAs Advising Clients on Asset Dispositions in an S Corporation

When advising clients on asset dispositions in an S corporation, CPAs must consider a variety of factors to ensure tax efficiency and compliance. Key considerations include:

  1. Recognition Period and Timing:
    • CPAs should assess whether it’s advantageous for the corporation to hold onto assets until the five-year recognition period has expired to avoid the built-in gains tax. If immediate asset sales are necessary, alternative strategies, such as installment sales or exchanges, should be evaluated.
  2. Asset Mix and Potential Offsets:
    • It’s important for CPAs to analyze the mix of assets held by the corporation, identifying both appreciated and underperforming assets. By coordinating the sale of assets with built-in losses alongside assets with built-in gains, CPAs can help offset gains and reduce the overall tax liability.
  3. Utilizing Tax Deferral Strategies:
    • CPAs must explore deferral opportunities such as like-kind exchanges under Section 1031, installment sales, or other tax-advantaged methods. These strategies can reduce the immediate impact of the BIG tax by spreading out the recognition of gains over time or deferring the recognition until a future taxable event.
  4. Long-Term Tax Planning Implications:
    • The impact of any asset sale or disposition should be considered in the context of long-term tax planning. For example, a like-kind exchange may defer tax but could have implications for future sales or liquidity needs. CPAs should weigh short-term tax savings against potential long-term outcomes.
  5. Impact on Shareholder Taxation:
    • Since S corporations are pass-through entities, asset dispositions and related gains are ultimately passed through to the shareholders. CPAs must assess how these transactions affect shareholders’ individual tax liabilities and plan accordingly. This may involve planning for distributions or other shareholder-level tax concerns.
  6. Compliance with IRS Requirements:
    • Finally, CPAs must ensure that all strategies used to minimize BIG tax, including Section 1031 exchanges, charitable contributions, or tax-free reorganizations, meet IRS requirements. Noncompliance or improper structuring of transactions could lead to disqualification of the tax benefits, resulting in unexpected tax liabilities.

Example:
A client plans to sell a commercial property with a significant built-in gain within the recognition period. As their CPA, you might recommend deferring the sale using a Section 1031 exchange, where the client can acquire a similar property without immediately triggering the BIG tax. You would also ensure all documentation is complete, including an accurate valuation at the time of conversion, and that a qualified intermediary facilitates the exchange to comply with IRS rules.

Effective tax planning and thorough documentation are crucial for minimizing built-in gains tax for S corporations. CPAs must take a proactive approach to identify opportunities for deferral or offset, ensure compliance with IRS regulations, and provide clients with tax-efficient strategies for managing their asset dispositions.

Conclusion

Recap of Key Strategies to Minimize Built-in Gains Tax

Minimizing built-in gains (BIG) tax requires a thoughtful and proactive approach to tax planning. Several key strategies can help S corporations reduce or defer their BIG tax liabilities:

  1. Timing the Disposition: One of the most straightforward strategies is to hold appreciated assets until the five-year recognition period expires. By delaying asset dispositions beyond this period, S corporations can avoid BIG tax entirely on built-in gains.
  2. Offsetting Gains with Built-in Losses: Selling assets with built-in losses can offset built-in gains from appreciated assets, effectively reducing the taxable gains and lowering the overall tax liability.
  3. Installment Sales: Structuring a sale as an installment sale allows the corporation to spread the recognition of gains over multiple years, potentially deferring or minimizing the BIG tax liability during the recognition period.
  4. Cost Segregation and Accelerated Depreciation: By accelerating depreciation on certain components of real property, the corporation can reduce the tax basis of the asset more quickly, thereby lowering the built-in gain subject to BIG tax upon disposition.
  5. Charitable Contributions of Appreciated Property: Contributing appreciated assets to a charity enables the corporation to avoid recognizing built-in gains and receive a charitable deduction, providing both tax savings and philanthropic benefits.
  6. Like-Kind Exchanges (Section 1031): Using Section 1031 exchanges allows the corporation to defer recognition of built-in gains by exchanging appreciated real property for other like-kind real property, avoiding immediate tax liability.
  7. Tax-Free Reorganizations and Liquidations: Under certain conditions, tax-free reorganizations or liquidations can allow the corporation to restructure or distribute assets without triggering the BIG tax.

Final Thoughts on the Importance of Proactive Tax Planning for S Corporations with Appreciated Assets

Proactive tax planning is essential for S corporations that hold appreciated assets, especially those that have converted from C corporation status. The built-in gains tax can significantly impact the financial outcome of asset dispositions, making it critical for CPAs and tax professionals to carefully evaluate and implement strategies to minimize or defer this tax.

By understanding the nuances of built-in gains tax, including its triggers, exceptions, and mitigation strategies, CPAs can provide valuable guidance to their clients. Whether through deferral strategies, timing asset sales, or leveraging tax-free exchanges, proactive planning allows corporations to optimize their tax outcomes while maintaining flexibility in managing their assets.

In summary, the ability to minimize built-in gains tax depends on a combination of strategic timing, proper asset management, and adherence to IRS regulations. For S corporations with appreciated assets, these strategies can significantly reduce tax liabilities, preserve cash flow, and create opportunities for further growth and investment. Proactive tax planning ensures that corporations are well-positioned to navigate the complexities of the BIG tax and achieve favorable financial results.

Other Posts You'll Like...

Want to Pass as Fast as Possible?

(and avoid failing sections?)

Watch one of our free "Study Hacks" trainings for a free walkthrough of the SuperfastCPA study methods that have helped so many candidates pass their sections faster and avoid failing scores...