TCP CPA Exam: Implications of Terminating an S Corp Election

Implications of Terminating an S Corp Election

Share This...

Introduction

Brief Overview of the S Corporation Election and Its Purpose

In this article, we’ll cover the implications of terminating an S corp election. An S Corporation (S Corp) is a tax designation that allows a corporation to pass its income, losses, deductions, and credits directly to its shareholders, avoiding the double taxation typically associated with C Corporations. This tax structure can be highly beneficial for small to medium-sized businesses that meet the eligibility criteria. These criteria include being a domestic corporation, having no more than 100 shareholders (who must be U.S. citizens or residents), maintaining only one class of stock, and being owned by individuals, certain trusts, or estates.

The primary advantage of electing S Corp status is the ability to avoid the double taxation of corporate earnings and shareholder dividends. In an S Corporation, all income is taxed at the shareholder level, which can lead to significant tax savings. Additionally, this structure allows shareholders to use losses from the business to offset their other income, potentially reducing their overall tax liability.

However, electing S Corp status also comes with several restrictions, including limits on the types of shareholders allowed and limitations on fringe benefits for owners. These considerations play a critical role in determining whether this election is right for a business.

Importance of Understanding the Implications of Terminating the S Corp Election for Tax Purposes

While electing S Corp status offers many tax advantages, circumstances may arise where a corporation chooses—or is forced—to terminate its S Corp election. This can happen voluntarily through a revocation by the shareholders, or involuntarily due to failure to meet the eligibility requirements.

Understanding the tax implications of terminating an S Corp election is crucial because the corporation will revert to a C Corporation, which subjects the business to a different set of tax rules. The shift to C Corp status means that the corporation will now face double taxation: once at the corporate level on its earnings, and again at the shareholder level on dividends. Additionally, the handling of accumulated adjustments account (AAA), previously untaxed earnings and profits, and distributions to shareholders will differ after the termination. These factors can significantly impact the corporation’s tax liability and the personal tax situations of its shareholders.

Moreover, the timing of the termination, the business structure post-termination, and planning for distributions of retained earnings before the election ends are all important considerations. Without careful planning, terminating an S Corp election can result in unexpected tax burdens for both the corporation and its shareholders, making it vital to understand the full scope of the implications.

Reasons for Terminating an S Corp Election

Voluntary Termination by Shareholders

A voluntary termination of an S Corporation election occurs when the shareholders of the corporation decide that the S Corp status is no longer beneficial or appropriate for the business. This may happen for various reasons, such as a shift in business strategy, tax considerations, or growth that makes the C Corporation status more advantageous. To revoke the S Corp election voluntarily, shareholders holding more than 50% of the shares must consent to the termination.

The process involves submitting a revocation statement to the IRS, typically filed with Form 1120-S. The termination becomes effective on the date specified in the revocation, provided that it is timely filed. If no date is specified, the termination will take effect on the first day of the tax year in which the revocation is filed. This gives shareholders the flexibility to time the termination in a way that minimizes tax consequences.

Involuntary Termination

Involuntary termination of an S Corp election occurs when the corporation fails to meet the eligibility requirements outlined by the IRS. This could happen for several reasons, including changes in ownership structure or operational practices that violate the S Corp criteria. Unlike voluntary termination, involuntary termination is initiated by the IRS, and the corporation may not be aware of the problem until the IRS issues a notice.

When an S Corporation is involuntarily terminated, the corporation automatically reverts to a C Corporation, subjecting it to corporate-level taxation. This can lead to unforeseen tax consequences for both the business and its shareholders. It is crucial for S Corporations to regularly monitor their compliance with the S Corp requirements to avoid this situation.

Revocation Due to Exceeding Allowable Shareholder Limits or Ineligible Shareholders

One of the key requirements for maintaining S Corp status is that the corporation must have no more than 100 shareholders. If the number of shareholders exceeds this limit, the S Corp election will be revoked. Additionally, all shareholders must be eligible individuals or entities. If an ineligible shareholder—such as a non-resident alien, corporation, or partnership—acquires shares in the S Corporation, the S Corp status is automatically terminated.

To prevent this type of revocation, S Corporations need to be diligent in tracking shareholder information and ensuring compliance with the allowable shareholder rules. An inadvertent violation of these rules could lead to significant tax consequences if the S Corp election is terminated unexpectedly.

Failure to Meet the “One Class of Stock” Requirement

S Corporations are required to have only one class of stock. This means that all shares must provide identical rights to distributions and liquidation proceeds. While voting rights can differ, the financial rights of the shares must remain the same across all shareholders.

If the corporation issues a second class of stock, whether intentionally or unintentionally, the IRS will revoke the S Corp election. This can happen, for example, if a corporation creates different stock options that alter the economic rights of shareholders. Once the S Corp election is revoked, the corporation reverts to C Corp status, with all the accompanying tax implications.

Maintaining compliance with the one-class-of-stock rule is essential for preserving S Corp status. Careful legal and tax planning is necessary when structuring stock options or bringing in new investors to avoid violating this critical requirement.

Process of Terminating an S Corp Election

Voluntary Revocation Procedure

Voluntarily terminating an S Corp election requires careful attention to both the procedural steps and the timing of the revocation to minimize any potential tax liabilities.

Filing Form 1120-S (Revocation Statement)

To initiate a voluntary termination of the S Corp election, shareholders holding more than 50% of the shares must agree to the revocation. The corporation then needs to submit a revocation statement to the IRS, typically filed with Form 1120-S. The revocation statement must include the following:

  • A clear statement indicating the corporation’s intent to terminate its S Corp election.
  • The name, address, and Employer Identification Number (EIN) of the corporation.
  • The specific date on which the revocation is to be effective (if applicable).
  • The signatures of shareholders who hold more than 50% of the voting and non-voting stock, confirming their consent to the revocation.

This document should be attached to the corporation’s Form 1120-S when filing, or it can be mailed directly to the IRS. The company may want to consult with a tax professional to ensure all required information is included, as an incomplete or incorrectly filed revocation can delay the process or lead to unintentional tax consequences.

Timing of Revocation (Effective Dates, Retroactive Revocation, etc.)

The timing of the revocation is critical and can have a significant impact on the corporation’s tax obligations. Generally, if no effective date is specified, the termination will take place on the first day of the tax year in which the revocation is filed. However, shareholders can specify a different effective date in the revocation statement, which can help manage the tax consequences for both the corporation and its shareholders.

A retroactive revocation is also possible under certain circumstances, as long as the revocation is filed within 2 ½ months of the start of the tax year. This allows the S Corp status to be revoked as of the beginning of the tax year, enabling the corporation to retroactively assume C Corporation status for that year. This flexibility allows businesses to align the termination with their tax planning strategies.

Involuntary Revocation and Notification from the IRS

An S Corp election can also be terminated involuntarily if the corporation no longer meets the eligibility requirements. This could occur due to changes in the number or type of shareholders, issuance of a second class of stock, or other noncompliance with S Corp rules.

In the case of an involuntary termination, the IRS will notify the corporation, typically by issuing a notice stating the reasons for the termination and the effective date. Upon receiving the notice, the corporation should immediately review the reasons for termination and determine whether they can resolve the issue to reinstate S Corp status. In some cases, the IRS may grant relief for inadvertent terminations if the corporation takes corrective actions.

If the revocation is not correctable, the corporation will revert to C Corporation status as of the termination date, subjecting it to corporate-level taxation. This can lead to significant tax consequences, particularly for shareholders accustomed to the pass-through taxation of an S Corp.

Impact of State Tax Laws and Possible Need for State-Specific Terminations

In addition to federal tax considerations, state tax laws must also be taken into account when terminating an S Corp election. Many states recognize the federal S Corp election, but not all states follow federal rules regarding revocation and termination. Some states may require separate filings or have additional tax consequences when terminating the S Corp election.

For example, a state might require a corporation to file a separate revocation notice to officially terminate its S Corp election for state tax purposes. Additionally, some states may not allow S Corp status at all, while others may impose different tax treatment on S Corps that are not mirrored by federal law.

It’s crucial to review state-specific tax laws and consult with a tax advisor to ensure compliance with both federal and state requirements when terminating an S Corp election. This can help avoid penalties or additional taxes that could arise from the termination process.

Tax Implications of Terminating an S Corp Election

Terminating an S Corp election can have significant tax implications, both at the corporate level and for individual shareholders. The tax consequences vary depending on whether the corporation transitions to a C Corporation or another business structure, such as a partnership. Key considerations include the impact of double taxation, the treatment of retained earnings, and how prior S Corp losses and credits are carried over after the termination.

Conversion from S Corp to C Corp or Partnership

When an S Corporation terminates its election, it typically reverts to a C Corporation. In this scenario, the company becomes subject to corporate-level taxation, meaning the corporation itself will now pay taxes on its earnings. Additionally, shareholders will be taxed on any dividends they receive, creating a double taxation situation.

Alternatively, in some cases, an S Corp may convert to a partnership or other entity, depending on the corporation’s structure and state laws. In these cases, the business would follow the tax treatment rules specific to the new entity type, such as pass-through taxation in a partnership.

The choice of structure post-termination will have a significant impact on future tax liabilities, and corporations may want to carefully consider this when deciding on the timing and strategy for the termination.

Impact on Corporate-Level Taxes (e.g., Double Taxation in C Corp Status)

One of the most important tax implications of terminating an S Corp election is the shift from pass-through taxation to double taxation. As a C Corporation, the company is now taxed at the corporate level on its profits. When those profits are distributed to shareholders as dividends, the shareholders must pay taxes on that income as well.

This double taxation can increase the overall tax burden significantly compared to the single layer of taxation that S Corps enjoy. For corporations with substantial earnings, this shift could lead to higher overall tax liabilities and influence decisions about how and when to distribute earnings to shareholders.

Treatment of Accumulated Adjustments Account (AAA)

The Accumulated Adjustments Account (AAA) is a critical component in determining the tax treatment of distributions after an S Corp election is terminated. The AAA represents the cumulative income or losses of the S Corporation that have not yet been distributed to shareholders but have been taxed at the shareholder level.

Upon termination of the S Corp election, distributions made from the AAA are generally treated as non-taxable return of capital, reducing the shareholder’s basis in the stock. However, once the AAA is depleted, any additional distributions will be treated as taxable dividends to the shareholders, as they are considered distributions of earnings and profits from the C Corporation.

Proper management of the AAA before and after termination is crucial to avoid unintended tax consequences, especially if significant earnings are to be distributed after the termination.

Distribution of Retained Earnings Before and After Revocation

Distributions of retained earnings from an S Corporation before termination are typically tax-free to the extent they do not exceed the shareholders’ basis in their stock. However, after the termination, the tax treatment of distributions changes significantly.

If the corporation transitions to a C Corp, any retained earnings accumulated after the termination are subject to corporate-level taxes when earned. When distributed to shareholders, these earnings will be treated as taxable dividends, leading to double taxation. To minimize the impact of this, S Corps may choose to distribute as much of their retained earnings as possible before revocation to take advantage of the favorable pass-through tax treatment.

Carryover of S Corp Losses and Credits to C Corp (Limitation Rules)

Another key tax consideration when terminating an S Corp election is the treatment of carryover losses and tax credits. S Corporations can pass through net operating losses (NOLs) and credits to shareholders, allowing them to offset personal income taxes. However, when the election is terminated, these losses and credits may be subject to limitations.

Upon conversion to C Corp status, the carryover of unused S Corp losses and credits becomes more restricted. The corporation may no longer be able to pass losses through to shareholders. Additionally, certain credits, such as the research and development (R&D) credit, may be carried forward, but their application may be limited by corporate tax rules.

Corporations should evaluate their current tax position, including any carryforward losses or credits, to ensure that they maximize the benefits before the S Corp election is terminated.

LIFO Recapture Tax for Revocation (if applicable)

For S Corporations that use the Last-In, First-Out (LIFO) inventory accounting method, a special tax rule known as the LIFO recapture tax applies when the election is terminated, and the corporation reverts to C Corp status. The LIFO recapture tax is designed to recapture the tax benefit gained from using the LIFO method during the S Corp years.

The LIFO recapture amount is calculated as the excess of the inventory value under the First-In, First-Out (FIFO) method over the LIFO value. This difference is subject to tax, and the corporation must include the LIFO recapture amount in its taxable income for the final S Corp year.

To ease the burden, the tax can be paid over four years in equal installments. However, the recapture tax can be significant for businesses with large LIFO reserves, so careful planning is essential to mitigate the impact of this tax when terminating the S Corp election.

Shareholder-Level Tax Implications

When an S Corp election is terminated, the tax treatment for shareholders changes significantly, particularly regarding stock basis, distributions, and income reporting. Understanding how these changes impact shareholders is essential for tax planning and minimizing unexpected tax burdens.

Change in Shareholder Basis in Stock

One of the most immediate consequences for shareholders following the termination of an S Corp election is the change in how their basis in the stock is treated. Under S Corp rules, a shareholder’s basis in the stock is adjusted annually based on the corporation’s income, losses, and distributions. In general, pass-through income increases the shareholder’s basis, while losses and distributions decrease it.

Once the S Corp election is terminated and the corporation reverts to C Corp status, these annual basis adjustments stop. From this point forward, the shareholder’s stock basis will only change when additional stock is purchased or sold. Importantly, future distributions made by the C Corp do not reduce the shareholder’s basis, but instead are treated as taxable dividends, making it crucial for shareholders to calculate their stock basis accurately before and after the termination to avoid tax surprises.

Tax Treatment of Distributions After Termination

Before termination, distributions from an S Corp are typically tax-free to the extent they do not exceed the shareholder’s basis in the stock. However, after the termination of the S Corp election, distributions are treated differently. If the corporation becomes a C Corp, any distributions made from the C Corp’s earnings and profits (E&P) are taxed as dividends to the shareholders, and these dividends are subject to tax at both the corporate and individual levels.

Additionally, if the distribution exceeds the corporation’s earnings and profits, the excess may be treated as a return of capital, which would reduce the shareholder’s stock basis. Once the shareholder’s basis is reduced to zero, any further distributions would be taxed as capital gains. This dual layer of taxation—corporate tax on earnings and individual tax on dividends—results in the “double taxation” that C Corps are known for, making it essential for shareholders to plan ahead if they expect significant post-termination distributions.

Effect on Pass-Through Income and Loss Treatment

A major advantage of S Corp status is the pass-through of income and losses to shareholders, which means that the corporation itself does not pay federal income tax. Instead, shareholders report their share of the corporation’s income or losses on their personal tax returns, allowing them to offset other personal income with losses from the corporation.

Once the S Corp election is terminated, this pass-through treatment ends, and the corporation will be subject to tax at the entity level (as a C Corp). Shareholders will no longer be able to claim a share of the company’s income or losses on their personal tax returns. This shift can have a significant impact on shareholders who had previously benefited from deducting losses against their personal income. Any unused S Corp losses prior to the termination may still be deductible, but limitations apply, and the carryover rules for losses and credits may no longer be as advantageous.

Shareholder Capital Gains and Dividend Income Considerations

After the termination of the S Corp election, the tax treatment of shareholder income shifts from pass-through income to capital gains and dividend income. Specifically, distributions made from the C Corp’s earnings will now be taxed as dividends. The dividend tax rates vary depending on the shareholder’s income level, but they are generally lower than ordinary income tax rates. However, since the corporation already pays taxes on the earnings before distributing dividends, shareholders are subject to double taxation, which increases the overall tax burden.

In addition to dividends, shareholders may also face capital gains tax if they sell their stock in the corporation. The capital gain or loss will be calculated as the difference between the sale price and the shareholder’s adjusted basis in the stock. If the shareholder’s basis in the stock was reduced due to prior S Corp distributions, any gain upon sale could be larger, leading to a higher capital gains tax.

This change in tax treatment makes it important for shareholders to consider the timing of stock sales and distributions, as well as their overall tax strategy, once the S Corp election is terminated. By understanding how post-termination distributions and stock sales are taxed, shareholders can plan ahead to minimize their tax liabilities and take advantage of favorable tax rates where possible.

Impact on Fringe Benefits and Employee Compensation

Terminating an S Corp election has significant consequences for how fringe benefits and employee compensation are treated from a tax perspective. These changes primarily affect shareholders, especially those owning more than 2% of the company, and can alter their tax liabilities related to fringe benefits and self-employment taxes.

How Termination Affects S Corp’s Ability to Provide Certain Fringe Benefits (e.g., Health Insurance Premiums for >2% Shareholders)

Under S Corp rules, shareholders who own more than 2% of the company are treated as self-employed for purposes of certain fringe benefits, including health insurance. Specifically, the cost of health insurance premiums paid by the S Corporation on behalf of these shareholders must be included in their wages for federal income tax purposes. However, the shareholders can typically deduct these health insurance premiums on their personal tax returns, reducing their overall tax burden.

When the S Corp election is terminated and the company converts to a C Corporation, the treatment of fringe benefits changes significantly. C Corporations are generally able to offer a broader range of tax-free fringe benefits to their employees, including health insurance, group-term life insurance, and more, without the same restrictions that apply to S Corp shareholders.

For shareholders who were previously limited by the S Corp’s rules, this change can be beneficial, as they may now be eligible to receive these benefits tax-free, similar to regular employees. However, if the corporation transitions to another structure, such as a partnership, the tax treatment of fringe benefits may differ, and shareholders will need to evaluate how these changes affect their overall compensation package.

Changes in Self-Employment Tax Treatment for Shareholders

One of the key advantages of S Corp status is the ability to minimize self-employment taxes. S Corporation shareholders do not pay self-employment taxes on their share of the company’s income. Instead, they only pay self-employment tax on the salary they receive as employees of the company. This allows S Corp shareholders to receive a portion of their income as distributions, which are not subject to self-employment tax, thereby reducing their overall tax liability.

However, when the S Corp election is terminated and the company reverts to C Corporation status, this self-employment tax benefit is no longer available. Shareholders in a C Corp do not receive distributions in the same way as S Corp shareholders, and instead, they are taxed on any dividends they receive. Importantly, dividends are not subject to self-employment tax, but they are subject to income tax, which is typically lower than the combined self-employment tax rate.

If the company converts to a partnership or sole proprietorship, the tax consequences are different. In these structures, owners are typically subject to self-employment tax on their share of the business’s income. This could lead to a higher overall tax burden for shareholders who were previously able to avoid self-employment taxes on distributions under the S Corp structure.

Understanding these changes is crucial for shareholders to accurately plan for their tax obligations post-termination, as the shift from S Corp status can significantly alter their tax liabilities related to both compensation and fringe benefits.

Tax Planning Considerations

Proper tax planning is essential when terminating an S Corp election, as it can significantly affect both the corporation’s and shareholders’ tax liabilities. By carefully considering the timing of the termination, the distribution of earnings, and the potential impact on the business structure, companies can minimize the tax burden and avoid costly mistakes.

Timing the Termination to Minimize Tax Burden

The timing of an S Corp termination plays a critical role in determining the tax consequences. Choosing when to terminate the S Corp election can influence how income, losses, and distributions are taxed. For example, if the termination is effective at the beginning of the tax year, the corporation will be taxed as a C Corporation for the entire year, and shareholders will face double taxation on any earnings distributed as dividends. On the other hand, terminating mid-year may create a split-year tax situation, where part of the year is taxed as an S Corp and the remainder as a C Corp.

To minimize tax liabilities, companies should aim to time the termination when the corporate earnings and distributions are low. Additionally, if the S Corp has losses, timing the termination to maximize the use of these losses at the shareholder level (while still under S Corp status) can be beneficial. Retroactive termination within 2 ½ months of the start of the tax year can also help align the termination date with favorable tax planning goals.

Planning for Distribution of Accumulated Earnings Before Terminating the Election

Another key consideration is distributing accumulated earnings before terminating the S Corp election. As an S Corp, distributions of accumulated earnings are generally tax-free to shareholders to the extent they do not exceed the shareholder’s stock basis. Once the S Corp election is terminated and the company converts to C Corp status, future distributions will be subject to double taxation: first at the corporate level and then at the shareholder level as taxable dividends.

To avoid this double taxation, it is often advantageous for an S Corp to distribute as much of its accumulated earnings as possible before the termination. By doing so, shareholders can receive these funds tax-free (assuming sufficient basis) or at a reduced tax rate, depending on the situation. Proper planning is essential to ensure that the company maximizes the benefit of tax-free distributions under the S Corp rules before the transition.

Evaluating Whether Termination Benefits or Harms the Business Structure (C Corp vs. S Corp)

Determining whether the termination of the S Corp election benefits or harms the business depends on a variety of factors. The decision to revert to C Corp status might make sense for businesses that plan to reinvest profits rather than distribute them, as the C Corp tax structure allows earnings to accumulate within the company without immediate tax consequences at the shareholder level.

On the other hand, businesses that frequently distribute profits to shareholders may find that the double taxation of C Corps significantly increases their tax burden compared to the pass-through taxation of S Corps. Additionally, if the company expects to grow and attract outside investors, a C Corp structure might be more attractive, as it offers more flexibility in issuing stock and raising capital. The evaluation should consider the company’s current and future goals, the shareholder composition, and the nature of the business activities.

A careful analysis of these factors will help determine whether maintaining S Corp status or transitioning to a C Corp—or another entity type—provides the most tax-efficient structure for the business.

Opportunities to Reduce Built-in Gains Tax

One potential tax liability when terminating an S Corp election is the built-in gains (BIG) tax, which applies if the corporation was previously a C Corp before electing S Corp status. The BIG tax is triggered if the S Corp sells appreciated assets that it held when it was a C Corp. This tax is designed to prevent corporations from avoiding C Corp taxes by converting to S Corp status and immediately selling appreciated assets.

The built-in gains tax applies for a period of five years after the S Corp election is made, so careful planning is needed if the corporation holds appreciated assets. One way to reduce the BIG tax is to defer the sale of appreciated assets until after the five-year recognition period has passed, avoiding the tax entirely.

Additionally, careful planning around the timing of asset sales can minimize the impact of the BIG tax. If an S Corp plans to terminate its election, it may be beneficial to sell any appreciated assets while still under S Corp status (if the five-year period has passed) or delay such sales until after the termination, depending on the circumstances. Consulting with a tax professional is essential to evaluate the best strategy for minimizing the BIG tax when terminating the S Corp election.

Proper tax planning and evaluation of these factors can significantly reduce the tax burden associated with terminating an S Corp election, ensuring a smooth transition to the new tax structure.

Re-electing S Corp Status

Once an S Corporation election is terminated, either voluntarily or involuntarily, the corporation may wish to re-elect S Corp status at a later date. However, there are several restrictions and requirements to be aware of before re-electing, including limitations on when a new election can be made and conditions that must be satisfied to qualify again as an S Corporation.

Limitations on Re-Election of S Corp Status After Termination

After terminating an S Corp election, the IRS imposes restrictions on the ability to re-elect S Corp status. The most notable restriction is the five-year rule, which prevents the corporation from re-electing S Corp status for five years following the termination. This rule is designed to prevent corporations from frequently switching between C Corp and S Corp status to manipulate tax liabilities.

If the corporation attempts to re-elect S Corp status within the five-year period, the election will generally be invalid unless the IRS grants specific permission to allow the re-election sooner. Such permission is rarely granted and typically requires a showing of a significant change in circumstances since the initial termination. For this reason, businesses should carefully consider the long-term impact before terminating their S Corp election, as re-election is not an option for a substantial period.

Waiting Periods and Requirements (5-Year Rule)

The five-year waiting period starts on the effective date of the S Corp termination and extends through the following five tax years. During this time, the corporation will be treated as a C Corporation (or other applicable entity) for federal tax purposes. After the five-year period has passed, the corporation may file a new election to become an S Corp once again, provided it meets all eligibility requirements.

To re-elect S Corp status after the waiting period, the corporation must ensure that it satisfies all the standard S Corp eligibility criteria at the time of the new election. This includes having 100 or fewer eligible shareholders, only issuing one class of stock, and meeting the requirements related to shareholder types (i.e., only individuals, certain trusts, and estates can be shareholders). The corporation will also need to submit a new election (Form 2553) to the IRS to regain its S Corp status, and all shareholders must once again consent to the election.

For corporations that find the restrictions on re-election too limiting, it may be beneficial to carefully plan for alternatives, such as restructuring the business or exploring other entity types that may provide similar tax advantages.

Common Mistakes and Pitfalls in S Corp Termination

Terminating an S Corp election can have significant tax and financial consequences, and there are several common mistakes and pitfalls that corporations and shareholders should be aware of during this process. Failing to properly address these issues can lead to unexpected tax liabilities and other complications.

Failing to Understand the Double Taxation of C Corporations

One of the most significant changes when an S Corp reverts to a C Corporation is the introduction of double taxation. Under S Corp rules, income is passed through to shareholders, and they are taxed only once on their share of the profits. However, when an S Corp converts to a C Corporation, the company is subject to corporate-level taxes on its earnings. Then, when those earnings are distributed to shareholders as dividends, the shareholders are taxed again on the dividends received. This double taxation can significantly increase the overall tax burden compared to the single-layer taxation of an S Corp.

A common pitfall is failing to account for this double taxation in tax planning. Corporations that terminate their S Corp election without understanding how the shift to C Corp status will impact their tax liabilities may end up facing higher-than-expected taxes on future earnings and distributions. To avoid this, businesses should carefully evaluate the long-term tax implications before deciding to terminate their S Corp status.

Overlooking the LIFO Recapture Tax

For S Corporations that use the Last-In, First-Out (LIFO) inventory accounting method, the LIFO recapture tax can be a significant and often overlooked consequence of terminating the S Corp election. When an S Corp terminates its election and reverts to a C Corporation, the IRS imposes a LIFO recapture tax on the difference between the inventory’s value under the First-In, First-Out (FIFO) method and the LIFO method. This difference is added to the company’s taxable income in the final year of the S Corp status.

The LIFO recapture tax can be substantial, especially for businesses that have large LIFO reserves. A common mistake is failing to account for this tax when planning the termination, leading to an unexpected and potentially large tax liability. To mitigate the impact of the LIFO recapture tax, corporations may need to consider spreading the tax liability over four years or deferring the termination until a more tax-advantageous time.

Mismanagement of Accumulated Adjustments Account and Distributions

The Accumulated Adjustments Account (AAA) is a critical component in S Corp taxation, as it tracks the earnings of the corporation that have already been taxed at the shareholder level but not yet distributed. One of the common pitfalls in terminating an S Corp election is mismanaging the AAA and failing to properly handle distributions before and after the termination.

Distributions made from the AAA while the corporation is still an S Corp are generally tax-free to shareholders, to the extent they do not exceed the shareholder’s basis in the stock. However, once the corporation reverts to a C Corp, any distributions are treated as taxable dividends, subject to double taxation. A common mistake is not making sufficient distributions from the AAA before the termination, resulting in higher tax liabilities for shareholders when those earnings are distributed after the termination.

To avoid this pitfall, businesses should plan ahead and ensure that they distribute as much of the AAA as possible before the S Corp termination. This allows shareholders to receive those earnings tax-free, reducing the overall tax burden. Additionally, corporations must carefully manage their AAA records to ensure accurate reporting of distributions and avoid errors that could lead to IRS scrutiny.

By being aware of these common mistakes and pitfalls, businesses can better prepare for the tax consequences of terminating their S Corp election and avoid costly errors that could impact their financial health.

Conclusion

Recap of the Potential Consequences of Terminating an S Corp Election

Terminating an S Corp election is a significant decision that can have far-reaching tax and financial implications for both the corporation and its shareholders. The transition from S Corp to C Corp or another entity type alters the way income, distributions, and taxes are handled. Key consequences include the introduction of double taxation under C Corp status, changes in how shareholder distributions are taxed, the potential for LIFO recapture tax, and the loss of pass-through treatment for income and losses. Additionally, the treatment of accumulated adjustments accounts (AAA) and shareholder basis can complicate the transition, leading to unexpected tax liabilities if not properly managed.

Careful planning is essential to mitigate these consequences, especially when it comes to timing the termination, distributing earnings before the shift, and handling post-termination income and benefits. Each of these factors can influence the tax burden faced by both the corporation and shareholders.

Final Thoughts on Evaluating the Decision and Consulting a Tax Professional Before Proceeding

Given the complexity and potential risks involved in terminating an S Corp election, it is crucial for corporations and their shareholders to carefully evaluate whether the termination is the best course of action. Key considerations include whether the corporation will benefit from reverting to C Corp status or another structure, the timing of the termination to minimize tax impacts, and the treatment of retained earnings and fringe benefits.

Additionally, the tax laws surrounding S Corp terminations are intricate and require careful navigation. Consulting a qualified tax professional is strongly recommended to ensure that all tax obligations are understood and to help develop a strategy that minimizes potential tax liabilities. A tax advisor can provide valuable insights into the consequences of termination, assist with compliance, and help structure the transition in the most tax-efficient manner possible.

By taking a thoughtful and informed approach, businesses can avoid common pitfalls and make a decision that supports their long-term financial goals while minimizing the tax burden associated with terminating their S Corp election.

Other Posts You'll Like...

Want to Pass as Fast as Possible?

(and avoid failing sections?)

Watch one of our free "Study Hacks" trainings for a free walkthrough of the SuperfastCPA study methods that have helped so many candidates pass their sections faster and avoid failing scores...